"We can just extend the (generous of our time/effort) help and then hope that whomever can benefit from it, sucks it up and does something with it.

In cases where the original poster is asking for some particular thing, I think viable options to that, especially if they are easier or more elegant should also be allowed into the discussion."

I agree, but at the same time the question should be answered and if it is a bad idea, why is it a bad idea. Many people would benefit from that information as well, including me.